From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Thurston v. Frank

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Dec 16, 1913
139 P. 124 (Okla. 1913)

Opinion

No. 5005

Opinion Filed December 16, 1913. Rehearing Denied March 10, 1914.

COLLECTION OF TAXES — Injunction — Former Opinion Followed. Reversed and remanded, on the authority of Thurston, County Treas., v. Caldwell et al., ante, 137 P. 683.

(Syllabus by the Court.)

Error from District Court, McClain County; R. McMillan, Judge.

Suit for an injunction by J. J. Frank and others, trustees, etc., against J. B. Thurston, County Treasurer of McClain County. Decree for plaintiffs, and defendant brings error. Reversed and remanded.

Wayne Wadlington, Co. Atty., and Warren K. Snyder, for plaintiff in error.

J. W. Hocker, for defendants in error.


This was a suit in equity, commenced by the defendants in error, plaintiffs below, against the plaintiff in error, as county treasurer of McClain county, defendant below, for the purpose of enjoining said treasurer from advertising and selling, and from collecting, or attempting to collect, for the years 1911 and 1912, certain taxes levied and assessed against certain property belonging to the Independent Order of Odd Fellows, situated in the city of Purcell, for school, municipal, and county purposes. Upon trial to the court, there was judgment and decree as prayed for, to reverse which this proceeding in error was commenced.

As upon the face of the petition the questions appear to be the same as those passed upon by this court in Thurston, County Treas., v. Caldwell et al., ante, 137 P. 683, and there is a stipulation to the effect that the briefs filed in that case shall be considered in this, this case must be controlled by the decision of this court in the other case.

Upon the authority of Thurston, County Treas., v. Caldwell et al., supra, the judgment and decree of the court below are reversed, and the cause remanded, with directions to proceed in accordance with the views of this court as expressed in Thurston, County Treas., v. Caldwell et al., supra.

All the Justices concur.


Summaries of

Thurston v. Frank

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Dec 16, 1913
139 P. 124 (Okla. 1913)
Case details for

Thurston v. Frank

Case Details

Full title:THURSTON, County Treas., v. FRANK et al

Court:Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Date published: Dec 16, 1913

Citations

139 P. 124 (Okla. 1913)
139 P. 124

Citing Cases

Trustees', Executors' Securities Ins. v. Hooton

"Section 20, art. 10, Williams' Annotated Constitution of Oklahoma, which provides, 'The Legislature shall…

Rogers v. Bass Harbour Co.

"constitute a limitation upon the power of the Legislature of the state to impose taxes for purposes which,…