From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Thatcher v. Miller

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Jun 16, 1931
300 P. 403 (Okla. 1931)

Opinion

No. 22254

Opinion Filed June 16, 1931.

(Syllabus.)

Appeal and Error — Moot Questions not Decided.

This court will not decide a case wherein the question presented for review has become moot and from which no practical result can follow.

Original action by Ed T. Thatcher et al. against Freeman E. Miller, Judge of District Court of Payne County, to determine the validity of suspension of petitioners from the office of County Commissioners of Payne County. Dismissed.

Brown Moore and Thomas Higgins, for petitioners.

J.M. Springer, for respondent.


This is an action in this court for writ of certiorari seeking a certification to this court for review of the records in the district court of Payne county in a proceedings, wherein the petitioners were suspended from office as county commissioners of Payne county upon accusation presented by a grand jury convened in said county.

The writ was granted on April 17, 1931, and the records duly certified to in this court. The ouster proceedings against the petitioners, in the district court of Payne county, were dismissed on May 7, 1931, and the cause is now before this court on motion of the respondents to dismiss the action for the reason the question presented by this action has become moot.

The dismissal of the accusation in the trial court is admitted by the petitioners. The dismissal of the accusation against the petitioners in the court in which the same was pending automatically restores the petitioners to office, and as this proceeding is brought to test the validity of the order of suspension, the question presented herein has become moot, and where the question raised by the proceedings has become moot, this court will not further consider it. State v. Blake, 138 Okla. 241, 280 P. 833. Wimmer v. State, 138 Okla. 241, 280 P. 830; City of Sapulpa v. Harris, 143 Okla. 69, 287 P. 1041. For the reasons herein set forth, this cause is dismissed.


Summaries of

Thatcher v. Miller

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Jun 16, 1931
300 P. 403 (Okla. 1931)
Case details for

Thatcher v. Miller

Case Details

Full title:THATCHER et al. v. MILLER, Dist. Judge

Court:Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Date published: Jun 16, 1931

Citations

300 P. 403 (Okla. 1931)
300 P. 403