From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Short v. Fleetwood Motor Homes of Pennsylvania, Inc.

District Court of Appeal of Florida, Fifth District
Aug 27, 1987
511 So. 2d 747 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 1987)

Summary

In Short v. Fleetwood Motor Homes of Pennsylvania, Inc., 511 So.2d 747 (Fla. 5th DCA 1987), the court held that Martin-Johnson precluded certiorari review of an order compelling discovery of certain financial information despite their agreement that the requested discovery was irrelevant to any issue presented by the case.

Summary of this case from Pearce v. Doral Mobile Home Villas

Opinion

No. 87-549.

August 27, 1987.

Charles B. Draper, Kissimmee, for petitioners.

E. Peyton Hodges of Cameron, Marriott, Walsh Hodges, P.A., Orlando, for respondents.


This petition for writ of certiorari seeks review of an order compelling production of income tax returns and financial records. Because petitioners are not seeking damages relating to their loss of income or earnings we can discern no proper reason for requiring the production of their personal financial records. The issues for decision below are whether the defendant is liable for the injury and if so, how much it must pay for medical expenses, pain, suffering, mental anguish, inconvenience and disability. An additional spousal claim for loss of services, companionship and consortium is also claimed. None of these is related to the income of the claimants. Poor and rich alike are due to be compensated in like amount for negligent injury. Should respondent need to see financial records regarding past medical expenditures to determine questions regarding preexisting injuries or conditions, then a specific demand can be made in this regard.

We perceive error, then, and would grant the writ, and were prepared to do so, but as preparations to do so had been begun the supreme court issued its opinion in Martin-Johnson, Inc. v. Savage, 509 So.2d 1097 (Fla. 1987). This ruling of our supreme court takes from petitioners their right to seek review of the order. We are bound to deny the writ.

Writ denied.

ORFINGER and COWART, JJ., concur.


Summaries of

Short v. Fleetwood Motor Homes of Pennsylvania, Inc.

District Court of Appeal of Florida, Fifth District
Aug 27, 1987
511 So. 2d 747 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 1987)

In Short v. Fleetwood Motor Homes of Pennsylvania, Inc., 511 So.2d 747 (Fla. 5th DCA 1987), the court held that Martin-Johnson precluded certiorari review of an order compelling discovery of certain financial information despite their agreement that the requested discovery was irrelevant to any issue presented by the case.

Summary of this case from Pearce v. Doral Mobile Home Villas
Case details for

Short v. Fleetwood Motor Homes of Pennsylvania, Inc.

Case Details

Full title:MILDRED A. SHORT AND HARRY L. SHORT, PETITIONERS, v. FLEETWOOD MOTOR HOMES…

Court:District Court of Appeal of Florida, Fifth District

Date published: Aug 27, 1987

Citations

511 So. 2d 747 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 1987)

Citing Cases

Zebouni v. Toler

While certiorari review of discovery orders was not directly before the Supreme Court, at least one of our…

Pearce v. Doral Mobile Home Villas

The handful of published decisions which have relied upon Martin-Johnson appear to have construed the…