From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Miller v. Superintendent

Court of Appeals of Maryland
Dec 17, 1947
60 A.2d 189 (Md. 1947)

Summary

In Miller v. Superintendent, 190 Md. 741, 60 A.2d 189, George S. Miller was confined in Spring Grove State Hospital as the result of a trial in the Criminal Court of Baltimore where he pleaded "not guilty by reason of insanity".

Summary of this case from McElroy v. Director

Opinion

[H.C. No. 21, October Term, 1947.]

Decided December 17, 1947.

Habeas Corpus — Application for Leave to Appeal — Must Show Detention For or Confinement As Result of Criminal Prosecution.

Where an application for leave to appeal from refusal of a writ of habeas corpus does not show that applicant is detained for or confined as the result of a prosecution for a criminal offense, the Court of Appeals has no jurisdiction and the application must be denied. p. 742

Decided December 17, 1947.

Habeas corpus proceeding on petition of George S. Miller against Superintendent of the Spring Grove State Hospital for Insane. On petitioner's application for leave to appeal from refusal of writ.

Application denied.

Before MARBURY, C.J., DELAPLAINE, COLLINS, GRASON, HENDERSON, and MARKELL, JJ.


This is an application for leave to appeal from refusal of a writ of habeas corpus.

The application is filed by George S. Miller now confined in the Spring Grove State Hospital. According to a letter received from the superintendent of Spring Grove State Hospital, as a result of a trial in the Criminal Court of Baltimore City where the petitioner here plead "not guilty by reason of insanity," a judgment was entered "that the prisoner be committed to Spring Grove State Hospital for Insane, there to be confined until he shall have recovered his reason and be discharged by due course of law." Code 1939, Article 59, § 7. In the brief filed in this court, the petitioner questions the sufficiency of the evidence in his trial in the Criminal Court. As it does not appear that the petitioner here is "detained for or confined as the result of a prosecution for a criminal offense" this Court has no jurisdiction on appeal and the application must be denied. Acts of 1945, Chapter 702, Section 3D; Bailey v. Superintendent, 190 Md. 735, 60 A.2d 188.

Application denied, without costs.


Summaries of

Miller v. Superintendent

Court of Appeals of Maryland
Dec 17, 1947
60 A.2d 189 (Md. 1947)

In Miller v. Superintendent, 190 Md. 741, 60 A.2d 189, George S. Miller was confined in Spring Grove State Hospital as the result of a trial in the Criminal Court of Baltimore where he pleaded "not guilty by reason of insanity".

Summary of this case from McElroy v. Director

In Miller v. Superintendent of Spring Grove State Hospital, 190 Md. 741, 60 A.2d 189, we passed upon a previous application of this petitioner for leave to appeal from the denial of a writ of habeas corpus and pointed out in that case that: "as it does not appear that the petitioner here is `detained for or confined as the result of a prosecution for a criminal offense' this Court has no jurisdiction on appeal and the application must be denied.

Summary of this case from Miller v. Superintendent
Case details for

Miller v. Superintendent

Case Details

Full title:MILLER v . SUPERINTENDENT OF SPRING GROVE STATE HOSPITAL FOR INSANE

Court:Court of Appeals of Maryland

Date published: Dec 17, 1947

Citations

60 A.2d 189 (Md. 1947)
60 A.2d 189

Citing Cases

McElroy v. Director

This Court held in that case that Bailey was not "detained for or confined as the result of a prosecution for…

Moquin v. State

See also the case of Bailey v. Superintendent, 190 Md. 735, in which it was held that a patient in Spring…