From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Lloyd v. McWilliams

U.S.
Dec 15, 1890
137 U.S. 576 (1890)

Opinion

ERROR TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THE DISTRICT OF RHODE ISLAND.

No. 109.

Argued and submitted December 10, 1890. Decided December 15, 1890.

When a trial by jury in a Circuit Court is waived by agreement, and the case is tried by the court, no questions are open for revision here, unless the record shows a finding of facts in accordance with the provisions of Rev. Stat. §§ 649, 700; and in such case, when brought here, the judgment of the Circuit Court will be presumed to be right and will be affirmed, if it appears that that court had jurisdiction of the subject matter and of the parties.

Mr. J.P. Tucker for plaintiff in error. Mr. Charles Levi Woodbury was with him.

Mr. Assistant Attorney General Maury for defendant in error.


THIS was an action to recover duties alleged to have been illegally exacted. When the cause was reached on the docket, argument was began on the part of the plaintiff in error; but the court interrupted the counsel and declined to hear further argument. The case is stated in the opinion.


In this cause, trial by jury was waived by agreement of the parties in writing, duly filed, and the case was tried by the court. But the record discloses no finding upon the facts, either general or special, in accordance with the statute, (Rev. Stat. §§ 649, 700,) and no questions are therefore open to our revision as an appellate tribunal.

As the Circuit Court had jurisdiction of the subject matter and the parties, its judgment must be presumed to be right, and on that ground

Affirmed.


Summaries of

Lloyd v. McWilliams

U.S.
Dec 15, 1890
137 U.S. 576 (1890)
Case details for

Lloyd v. McWilliams

Case Details

Full title:LLOYD v . McWILLIAMS

Court:U.S.

Date published: Dec 15, 1890

Citations

137 U.S. 576 (1890)

Citing Cases

Saltonstall v. Birtwell

We are unable, therefore, to direct judgment for either party. Chesapeake Ins. Co. v. Stark, 6 Cranch. 268,…

Mason v. Robertson

The ruling below was in accordance with decisions in other circuits. Biddle v. Hartranft, 29 F. 90; Lloyd v.…