From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

In re Archambault

Supreme Court of Vermont
Nov 6, 1986
520 A.2d 154 (Vt. 1986)

Opinion

No. 85-511

November 6, 1986.

Appeal from Washington Superior Court.


Actions concerning the settlement of trust accounts are equitable in nature, and, when appealed from probate court, are to be heard by the superior court sitting as a court of equity. In re Weatherhead, 53 Vt. 653, 658 (1881).

Once invoked, equity retains jurisdiction over the entire action to see that complete relief is administered. Soucy v. Soucy Motors, Inc., 143 Vt. 615, 617, 471 A.2d 224, 225 (1983) (citing LaMantia v. King, 129 Vt. 628, 634-35, 285 A.2d 741, 745 (1971)). Entitlement to a jury trial is not determined by the presence of a legal issue in a case, but rather is dependent upon the relief requested; if the relief requested is equitable, no right to a jury trial exists. Merchants Bank v. Thibodeau, 143 Vt. 132, 134, 465 A.2d 258, 260 (1983).

Here, the ultimate relief requested is the approval (or disapproval) of the trustee's accounting, a matter that is equitable in nature. There is no right to a jury trial on legal issues raised in connection therewith.

Affirmed. Remanded for further proceedings.


Summaries of

In re Archambault

Supreme Court of Vermont
Nov 6, 1986
520 A.2d 154 (Vt. 1986)
Case details for

In re Archambault

Case Details

Full title:In re Trust Estate of Armand C. ARCHAMBAULT

Court:Supreme Court of Vermont

Date published: Nov 6, 1986

Citations

520 A.2d 154 (Vt. 1986)
147 Vt. 649

Citing Cases

State v. Irving Oil Corp.

See In re Estate of Gorton, 167 Vt. 357, 365, 706 A.2d 947, 952 (1997) ("[E]ntitlement to a jury trial `is…

In re Estate of Gorton

Thus, entitlement to a jury trial "is dependent upon the relief requested; if the relief requested is…